Designing Sound Before the First Speaker Is Installed
Sound-system design starts before choosing loudspeakers. Three-dimensional modelling helps venues compare credible options while architecture is still flexible.
Sound-system design starts before choosing loudspeakers. Three-dimensional modelling helps venues compare credible options while architecture is still flexible.
Walk into an empty venue and it's tempting to start imagining where the speakers will go. A pair near the stage, perhaps a few more along the walls, and some subwoofers wherever there's enough room.
It's a perfectly understandable starting point. After all, the speakers are the most visible part of a sound system.
But before choosing them, there's a more interesting question: how should sound behave in this space?
For a hotel lounge, restaurant or entertainment venue, the answer depends on considerably more than the room's dimensions. Where will guests sit? Will some areas be used for conversation while others accommodate dancing or live performances? How will the venue change throughout the evening? And what happens when the architecture doesn't offer convenient places to install equipment?
These are questions worth exploring while the design is still flexible.
We recently worked on two possible sound-system designs for the same hospitality venue, using L-Acoustics Soundvision modelling software.
The venue was intended primarily as a lounge, with occasional live performances. The objective was to provide a high-quality listening experience throughout the relevant guest areas while respecting the architecture and the different ways the space would be used.
Rather than simply deciding how many loudspeakers were needed, we explored two different approaches.
The first used L-Acoustics A10 loudspeakers, combining Focus and Wide models, with SB15m subwoofers. The second used the slender Syva and Syva Low system, supported by compact X6i loudspeakers.
Both were complete professional systems, but they approached the room differently.
The A10 configuration offered one way of directing sound across the audience areas. The Syva configuration offered another, with a different physical presence and approach to distributing sound through the venue.
Neither could be judged simply by counting loudspeakers or comparing specifications. The interesting question was how each configuration would perform in the actual space.
Soundvision allows a designer to build a three-dimensional representation of a venue, position loudspeakers within it and simulate their predicted sound coverage.
This is where the design process becomes particularly useful.
A loudspeaker that looks perfectly positioned on an architectural drawing may behave differently once its coverage pattern, mounting height and orientation are considered. A column may complicate the layout. An apparently convenient installation point may leave part of the audience poorly covered.
With a model, we can explore these questions before equipment is installed.
In our case, the simulations helped us examine how the two configurations would distribute sound across the venue and how their different loudspeaker arrangements would interact with its geometry.
The objective wasn't necessarily to achieve identical sound levels in every corner. A lounge doesn't need to behave like a laboratory, and different parts of a hospitality venue may serve different purposes.
What matters is understanding those differences and making deliberate choices.
One of the less obvious advantages of modelling is that it makes technical decisions easier to discuss with people who aren't audio specialists.
An architect may be concerned about how a loudspeaker fits into the interior. An F&B manager may be more interested in the experience of guests seated near the bar. An operator may want to understand how the system will accommodate different entertainment formats.
All are legitimate concerns, and all benefit from being considered before installation.
A three-dimensional model provides a common reference. Instead of asking a client to imagine the consequences of a technical specification, we can show the proposed positions and explain the predicted coverage.
L-Acoustics has also introduced Soundvision Connect, which extends this approach by allowing project designs to be shared and reviewed through a browser.
The potential is particularly interesting when several people are involved in a venue project. Sound-system design can become part of the wider architectural and operational discussion, rather than a specialist exercise conducted separately from everything else.
That doesn't mean every client needs to understand acoustic modelling. They need to understand the decisions that affect their venue.
A good model is an extremely useful planning tool, but it isn't a substitute for listening to the finished installation.
Soundvision predicts how a loudspeaker system distributes sound based on the model and the characteristics of the equipment. It doesn't provide a complete prediction of everything that will happen acoustically inside a finished room.
Reflections, reverberation, furnishings, construction materials and other factors can all influence what guests ultimately hear.
And, of course, the atmosphere of a venue is shaped by more than sound coverage. Music programming, lighting, the arrangement of the space and the way an evening develops all contribute to the experience.
The purpose of modelling is to make better-informed decisions early, then verify and refine the system once it has been installed.
The two configurations we explored illustrate something that is easy to overlook when purchasing a sound system: there can be more than one technically credible solution to the same brief.
The differences are not always obvious from a product catalogue.
They emerge when we consider the architecture, the intended guest experience, the installation possibilities and the way the venue will actually operate.
For hotels, restaurants and entertainment venues, this is a good reason to involve sound-system designers while there is still room to influence the project.
Moving a loudspeaker position in a three-dimensional model takes a few moments. Moving it after the interior has been completed can be a rather more expensive conversation.